In the short program Thomas was 2nd in the short to Witt and Manley 3rd. Had Manley been 2nd in the short she would have won gold over Witt since she was 4th in figures to Witt’s 3rd, and won the long program. 4 of 9 judges had Manley over Thomas in the short. The Canadian judge didnt. Had the Canadian judge had Manley over Thomas in the short she would have been 2nd in the short, and won the gold over Witt overall.